Bodie the ghost town

Bodie the ghost town.

Nestled amidst the majestic mountains of California lies Bodie, the legendary ghost town steeped in history and intrigue. With its crumbling facades and abandoned buildings, Bodie is a testament to the fleeting nature of man’s dreams and aspirations. A ghost town that once bustled with activity during the gold-mining era of the 1800s, Bodie now draws visitors from around the world who come to explore its mysteries and unearth its secrets.

bodie the ghost town

A short background to Bodie’s fame.

The history of Bodie reads like a thrilling novel, with twists and turns at every corner. Gold was discovered in 1859 and after that, Bodie quickly grew into a thriving metropolis that at its peak boasted a population of over 10,000. With its bustling streets and bustling businesses, Bodie was a beacon of prosperity and opportunity.

However, fame and glory would be short-lived. As the gold began to run dry, the population dwindled. By the beginning of 1900, Bodie was on the brink of collapse, and many of its buildings were left to the elements. But just as the town seemed destined to fade into obscurity, fate intervened, and Bodie was reborn as a State Historic Park in 1961. Today, Bodie stands as a testament to the tenacity and resilience of the human spirit, a haunting reminder of a bygone era that still captivates the imagination.

Paranormal activity in Bodie

Reports of ghosts in Bodie

The town of Bodie has long been renowned for its chilling paranormal activity, with countless reports of ghostly sightings permeating its eerie atmosphere. Visitors to the ghost town often report an unsettling presence, the faint echo of mysterious noises, and apparitions of a seemingly supernatural origin.

Visitors have claimed to have seen the ghost of a little girl in the old schoolhouse. There have been reports of the apparition of a woman in a white dress walking about at the cemetery. Some have felt cold spots, sudden gusts of wind, and other spectral sensations, despite the stillness of the surrounding air.

Bodie with mountains in the background

Haunted locations in Bodie

Numerous locations in Bodie are believed to be haunted, with the town’s cemetery being a hotspot of spectral activity. The cemetery is said to house the spirit of a man buried alive and the ghosts of several children who succumbed to a diphtheria outbreak.

The old schoolhouse is also reputed to be a hub of ghostly activity, with visitors reporting inexplicable noises and sightings of mysterious apparitions. The Dechambeau Hotel, a popular haunt for ghost hunters, has been associated with spectral voices and inexplicable footsteps, with guests claiming to have encountered unexplained phenomena during their stays.

Theories on why Bodie is haunted

Several theories exist to explain Bodie is haunted, with some speculating that the town’s violent past has imbued it with a metaphysical residue that continues to pervade the town. There are speculations that the spirits of those who perished during the town’s heyday still wander the streets, searching for a means to ascend to the afterlife.

Still, others believe that the gold that originally drew people to Bodie may have an esoteric energy that has imbued the town with an otherworldly presence. Ore that the town’s location on the fringe of a vast, untamed wilderness has attracted ghosts and paranormal activity, making uneasy presences approach from far and wide.

We don’t know the reason but Bodie’s reputation as a haunted destination has only grown over time. More and more curious visitors come from all corners of the globe, eager to explore its eerie and enigmatic past.

Ghost sightings in Bodie

Popular ghost stories from Bodie

Bodie the ghost town has many stories to tell. Among the most popular is the tale of the “little girl of Bodie,” a spectral child who is said to haunt the town’s schoolhouse. Visitors claim to have seen her apparition drifting through the halls, accompanied by the sound of her spectral laughter.

Another chilling tale is that of the “hanging tree,” a gnarled old tree located near the town’s cemetery, said to have been the site of many lynchings during Bodie’s heyday. Visitors claim to have seen the ghosts of the unfortunate souls who perished there, still hanging from its twisted branches.

inside the church of abandoned mining town

Photos and videos from Bodie the ghost town

Visitors to Bodie have captured photographic and video evidence of ghostly apparitions, lending further credence to the town’s reputation as a hotbed of paranormal activity. Photos and videos of spectral figures moving through the streets, mysterious orbs, and unexplained phenomena continue to circulate on social media and the internet, fueling the town’s eerie reputation and drawing in curious visitors from all corners of the globe.

Strange appearances in Bodie

Paranormal investigations and their conclusions

Over the years, many paranormal investigators and ghost hunters have come to Bodie. Unfortunately, we don’t have any official, professional reports. The stories are mostly of private character, Youtubers shooting video footage during opening hours in the daytime. We have some of the normal scraping EVPs (Electronic Voice Phenomena), occasional touching, temperature drops, and other inexplicable movements of objects. Nothing decisive. The conclusions have been varied and inconclusive.

Experts on ghosts and what they say

bodie the ghost town
Pat Garrett 1883

Some experts on the paranormal have weighed in on the phenomena in Bodie, offering their own unique perspectives on the town’s haunting reputation. It is possible though that the town’s violent past, with its many lynchings and shootouts, has made Bodie a perfect target for unverified ghost stories.

There is also the town’s isolated location and harsh climate to consider. It could be suggested that these factors may have contributed to the high levels of paranormal reports in Bodie.

The legend about the curse of the stolen objects of Bodie.

There is an old legend regarding Bodie. It is believed that if anyone takes something away from Bodie, they will suffer from a string of misfortunes until they return the artifact. Every day the Bodie State Historic Park receives letters and packages of stolen items with letters attached asking them to take them back.

– Please take back this rock. After stealing it, I’ve never suffered such bad luck in my life.

In past years, many visitors used to steal souvenirs from the town. That resulted in a massive loss of historical artifacts. One day a park ranger evidently came up with a solution. He simply invented the idea of the curse and started spreading it. And it worked.

After some time, the park started receiving letters and packages containing stolen items with pleas to lift the curse. And possibly the fake legend will prevent new thefts because returning an old artifact doesn’t really solve the problem. Once the item is back in Bodie, it is out of its context. And it’s often not an easy task to understand from where it was taken. The risk is that it remains in a box in a warehouse forever.

Other documentation of interest

“Ghosts of Bodie” – a book by author Margie Kay, exploring the town’s supernatural phenomena

“Bodie: The Town That Belongs to Ghosts” – an article published in the LA Times, examining the history and paranormal activity of Bodie

And of course an abundance of video documentaries, but unfortunately, none are very convincing.

Is Bodie haunted or not?

Walking through the deserted streets of Bodie is a surreal experience. The abandoned buildings stand as silent witnesses to a violent past, and the atmosphere is heavy with the weight of history. The site is awesome and any sound or wind blowing across the empty streets just increases the eerie feeling

Having said that, it’s not a paranormal spot. I can’t find anything pointing to Bodie being more than just an awesome old abandoned town… A historical document, a doorway to a violent past, and a reminiscence of the men and women who built the new world.

back to the top of the page

Conclusion.

Bodie is a wonderful place, a ghost town in the mountains of California. But it is not haunted. Although the empty buildings, the windswept open surroundings, and the isolated position can easily make it seem that way.

  • Bodie is located in the eastern Sierra Nevada mountains of California, about 75 miles southeast of Lake Tahoe.
  • Take Highway 395 to State Route 270, which leads directly to the park entrance.
  • The park is open year-round, but hours vary by season.
  • March – October, 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM.
  • November – February, 9:00 AM – 4:00 PM.
  • The park is closed on Thanksgiving, Christmas, and New Year’s Day.
  • Admission is $8 per person for visitors 18 years of age and older.
  • Visitors 4 – 17 years of age: $5
  • Under the age of 4 entrance is free of charge.
  • Visitors can purchase tickets at the park entrance.
  • Visitors are also reminded to not take any artifacts or souvenirs from the park, as it is illegal and can result in fines or prosecution. You may also be subject to the Curse of Bodie…

home

Bodie from a distance
Bodie in 1890

The horrific truth about the first genocide of the 20th century.

The horrific truth about the Namibia genocide 1904 – 1908.

Not many people know about this dark corner of human history. But the horrendous crimes against humanity by the Nazis before, and during WW2 weren’t the first example of German ethnic cleansing. Namibia became a German colony in 1884. Before that, The coastal territory and the southwest, where the diamond mines are situated today, were mostly inhabited by Nama and Herero divided into more groups.

Namibia genocide
Ohamakari – The Waterberg

Africa’s history is a long line of white supremacy, tyranny, oppression, and abuse by European imperialistic countries. But the Namibia genocide pushed the extent of the horrors to new limits.

In 1904, an uprising among the Herero in Okahandja, led to the German Reichstag sending 7000 men under the command of lieutenant general Lothar von Trotha to Namibia. These men were equipped with the best and most modern weapons of the German armed force. After thoroughly preparing, Trotha attacked the Herero army at Ohamakari, the Waterberg.

Commander of the Herero army 1904
Commander Samuel Maharero

Trotha completely overwhelmed the Herero army, but he left an opening for them to flee out into the Kalahari desert. Most of the Herero fighting soldiers died in the battle, but many of the women and children fled into the east. There they were chased by the German soldiers further into the desert. Trotha’s soldiers shot or stabbed to death any Herero still within the German territory, and it was officially declared that the aim was to liberate all of the lands of any Herero.

The Nama uprising.

The other ethnic group in the area, the Namas took up arms against the German troops. Under commander Hendrik Witbooi they effectively raided and attacked German forces between 1904 and 1905. Unfortunately, their rebellion was too small and too late. After many years of internal conflicts with the Hereros, Witbooi didn’t enter the war until well after the battle of Waterberg. And so Trotha’s army had already defeated the Hereros. As often the case in war, there was a lack of coordination.

Still, Witbooi was more successful than his Herero counterpart Chief Samuel Maharero. Instead of facing the Germans head-on, he led the Nama in a reasonably successful guerrilla war. Being much better equipped with knowledge about local geography and nature, and having better stamina, he effectively slowed down the German advances. When he was killed in battle on November 29, 1905, the Namas surrendered.

The butchering stopped.

Chief of the Nama army 1904
Chief Hendrik Witbooi

But let’s get back to the Herero-German war. Finally, the counter-order came from Berlin, and after months of hunting the Hereros, Trotha had to stop the slaughter. Chief Witbooi had fled to Botswana together with a handful of men. The remaining Hereros, mostly women, elderly, and children were half dead from starvation and dehydration after months in the Kalahari desert. The war was finished but the Namibia genocide had just started.

Because the German authorities in Namibia realized they needed manpower. And the indigenous groups other than Herero which they once could have depended on were now mostly avoiding them. And the Hereros themselves were obviously hiding. Still, it was deemed that it would be easier to lure out the shattered Hereros from the bush than try to battle other groups into submission or convince them to work for payment. Remember that by now, none of the Namibian peoples had any confidence left for the Europeans.

So, they sent forth the only ones the Hereros still thought they could trust… The missionaries. With promises of sanctuary in ” rescue”-camps they were persuaded to come out from their hiding. They thought they would be given food, clothing, and medical care. The truth was that very little of that was offered. Instead, they would have to work harder and for a longer time than any human being should ever be forced to do.

The concentration camps.

The term concentration camp was first used by the Spanish in Cuba, and later by the US and the English. The intention was to keep freedom fighters away from the civilians that supported them. It was a military strategy. In Namibia, the Germans took the whole idea one step further. In Namibia, there were no freedom fighters left for the civilians to support.

namibia genocide
A concentration camp in Windhoek. 1905

The camps were mainly of two types: Labour camps, and death camps. The labor camps were many and in different parts of the country. The camp intern got a number stamped on a metal tag, which he or she was ordered to wear at all times. The goal was to offer cheap labor to the German authorities, labor for which the army was paid. But the business was so profitable that even private enterprises entered the market.

The shipping company Woermann-Line had its own concentration camp in Swakopmund. It provided free slave labor for mainly loading and unloading their ships. 

The Namibian railroads 

Many of the buildings in Namibia from the period between 1904 and 1909 are built by slave labor. Even the parliament was built by slaves. But the biggest project of them all, the railway was almost exclusively built by Hereros in the years from 1904 until 1908

In the south, the railway connecting the port of Lüderitz to Keetmanshoop was constructed by Lenz & Co, a German railway construction and operating company. They too used slave labor from the concentration camps. In 1906 they were issued with prisoners to work at the railroad. The year after two-thirds of them were dead. Of 2014 prisoners in 1906, only 655 survived until 1907. 

Slaves in namibia

Shark Island.

But the worst of the concentration camps was shark island. Today it is a peninsula connected to the mainland, but at the beginning of 1900 it was still an island, and it was a forbidden territory. The prisoners who came to shark island weren’t supposed to work or do anything… They were supposed to die. It was an extermination camp of a model we have come to know too well. 

Shark island was off the grid, away from curious testimonies. The prisoners were apart from Hereros also Nama. The latter were according to the German authorities “of no use to the world anymore”. They were given very little food and water. And since there were almost no cooking possibilities, the prisoners had to eat the little rice or flower they had raw. The climate on the coast is cold and the prisoners had no clothing or enough blankets to protect themselves. Furthermore, they were inland people and not used to the strong and humid Atlantic winds.

Just as with the extermination of mostly Jews during the Nazi reign from 1933 to 1945 in Germany, the transports of prisoners to the island were done in boxcars. The prisoners were also not told where they were going, so as to not cause alarm among them. The rumors about shark island were such that the Germans feared rebellion or simply that the inmates could prefer suicide to go to the death camp. 

Lieutenant_von_Durling_
Shark Island prisoners together with Lieutenant von Durling
namibia genocide
Herero slaves in chains

Eugen Fischer, one of the architects of racial hygiene during the Nazi’s Third Reich.

Other connections to the war crimes by the Nazis later are illustrated by the German anthropologist Eugene Fischer. He came to Namibia in 1906, where he found a population of native African prisoners ready to be used in his horrendous studies. He and his colleagues did experiments on the prisoners. And the body parts of the dead were dissected and studied. 

Eugene Fischer investigated and later shipped 778 conserved heads of concentration camp prisoners to Germany. These relics were stacked away in basements of universities and high schools until 2011 when efforts were initiated to return them to Namibia for burial. This was completed in 2014.

Eugene Fischer’s ideas about race biology would later be influential in laws against mixed marriages. But further on they would be of much more importance than so. His work would become the backbone for racial hygiene efforts not only in Nazi Germany, but also in all of Europe, and other “western” countries until long after the war. Because we should never try to blame all of the race-thinking on the Nazis. These ideas flourished throughout the world, and maybe we still haven’t gotten rid of them completely even today.

Eugene Fischer’s work.

He co-wrote the book Principles of Human Heredity and Race Hygiene together with Erwin Baur and Fritz Lenz, published in 1921. That very book was thoroughly read by Adolf Hitler during his imprisonment in München in 1923, and it became the “scientific” basis for eugenic sterilization programs.

namibia genocide
German soldiers packageing skulls for shipping.

So, what was it with his fixation with skulls? 

He published several books.

  • In 1913 he published The Rehobother Bastards and the bastardization problem in humans. This work was described as combining the earlier Mendelism theories with anthropology. It would become something of a ground plate for the racial biology that swept over Europe in the early 1900s.  
  • In 1927 he co-wrote German heads of Nordic race, another book about heads. The theory was that one could determine characteristics by measuring the head of a person. Firstly, it was about “race”. But these theories were later used to identify all kinds of personalities… Criminal behavior, promiscuity, low intelligence, etc. And in countries surrounding Germany, these theories were used to maintain the possibility of forced sterilization all the way until the 1970s. 
  • In 1943 he co-wrote Das antike Weltjudentum (The ancient world Judaism). 

In 1942 he retired from his position as rector for the Humboldt University of Berlin. He was never prosecuted in the Nurnberg trials and he never answered for his crimes. He died in 1967 after having published two more books in the 1950s. 

What happened with the concentration camps after 1908?

The shark island camp was closed in 1907. The remaining prisoners were transferred to another concentration camp near Radford Bay, where they initially continued dying. They were in such a weakened state. Even so, the conditions in the new camp made the survival prospects a little better.

On April 1, 1908, the prisoner-of-war status for the camp interns was abolished. This meant that all of the concentration camps had to close. The surviving Hereros and Namas were distributed among German landowners and companies. The freed prisoners were also forbidden to own land and therefore they couldn’t go back to the pastoral activity they were used to. The situation didn’t improve in any radical way.

1918…

Statue to honor German soldiers in the Namibia genocide.
Reiterdenkmal. memorating the fallen German soldiers.

After the first world war, Germany lost all its colonies. But instead of a free state, German West Africa, as Namibia was called, became a part of the new Union of South Africa, and as such under South African (at that time under British dominion) rule. South Africa became an independent state in 1961. But already in 1948 the National Party introduced Apartheid laws and the people of Namibia found themselves back in a white European racial domination once more.

In 1966 the UN general assembly passed resolution 2145 that should bring the South African sovereignty to an end. But South Africa rejected it and kept its firm grip on Namibia. It would take 26 years to convince the southern African country to set its neighboring country free. On March 21, 1990, the Republic of Namibia was established. 86 years after the battle of Waterberg the Namibian people were finally masters of their own land.

The free republic of Namibia.

But the economy was still mostly in the hands of American, South African, and European companies… And is so til this day. And the land is continuously owned on a large scale by white descendants of German and South African landowners. Today, much effort is made to somehow equalize the economic situation even though many claim it’s not done enough.

In 2021 Germany officially asked the Namibian people for forgiveness for the atrocities committed during German rule. The word “genocide” was used for the first time. Namibia was also granted €1,1 billion in aid by the German government. It is given in 30 years and that makes it less than €40 million a year. That makes it in line with the yearly German DAC mandate aid to Namibia for the years 1990 – 2021. 

But what happened to the memories of the cruelties?

  • Shark island is now a camping site.
  • On top of what once was another camp in Windhoek today stands a German memorial statue, the Reiterdenkmal.
memorial headstone shark island
Courtesy of Johan Jönsson under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license.
  • A vast burial ground with unmarked graves of anonymous slave workers outside Lüderitz is now a popular motorcycle and quad track. 
  • At the foot of Ohamakari where the battle of Waterberg was fought, there lies a cemetery for fallen German soldiers.

In later years memorial monuments are being built in many locations all over Namibia. The complete lack of remembrance of the cruelties committed in the first years of the 20th century was brought to attention. So, for many years there was nothing on Shark Island that recorded all those who suffered and died there. But now there is a striking white headstone reading

We commemorate our Heroes. Captain Cornelius Fredericks. 1864-1907. With 167 men, 97 women, 66 children, the sons, daughters, and children of !Ama Community Bethanie Namibia.

Final thoughts.

I have no answers on how to compensate, how to restore, how to remember, or how to forgive. But I don’t think it is for the better to forget, to pretend that it didn’t happen.

There is a very long row of examples of how the African continent was abused, raped, and shackled for hundreds of years by European colonial initiatives. The case of Namibia is a shameful chapter of human history. And it shows us what stupidity, ignorance, and ambition can do to men.

But most of all is it a brutal vision of where illusions about supremacy and superiority can conduct us if we follow along in that direction. And as soon as we start thinking in terms of we, us, and those, the others, we have already taken the first step on that path. 

Top of the Page

namib desert

home

Was boiling oil used in sieges?

Was boiling oil used in sieges?

Though we have seen it in a myriad of Hollywood films… The defending troops await the enemy at the castle. And when they arrive, the soldiers in the stronghold open the secret trap doors above the big iron gate and pour hot oil on their adversaries. 

So, I set out to discover if it really was a realistic description of medieval warfare, the hot oil thingy… Was boiling oil used in sieges back then, in the middle ages?

Throwing things at the enemy from the security of the inside of the castle was a very common medieval defense strategy. The strong walls were difficult to break for the attacker and if they tried, they had to expose themselves to enemy fire. But to use burning oil was expensive, and in most places, they just didn’t have enough. Reports of hot sand and boiling water are far more common.

was boiling oil used in sieges

How did a siege work in medieval and ancient times?

First of all, we’re talking about a very long period. Things started changing in the 16th and 17th centuries when firearms became widely available. So, practically from when we first started building fortifications up until that time, we have situations with defenders inside some sort of wall and attackers outside trying to break in. 

Secondly, during this very long time, many ingenious weapons, structures, catapults, and methods were invented to be able to force the defenses. And all these methods were always heavily depending on the immediate geographical situation, the state of the attacking soldiers… As well as the defending soldiers, the supplies available, the time of year, the climate, and a whole lot of other factors. In short, no siege was the same as the other.

Wars, before guns, were fought with swords, pikes, bows, and lances. And if the enemy had taken refuge inside a castle with thick stone walls, these weapons were of little use. In fact, to break a castle defense you needed more than that.

Fortunately, for the attacker that is, such solutions existed. 

Siege weapons

siege tower
Siege Tower – A very big one.

Ladders.

This was the simplest, most straightforward method to conquer a stronghold. It was also the most expensive in cost of lives. To raise ladders against the castle wall you would need a massive attack force, and death-defying soldiers. Because you give the defenders every possibility to shoot arrows, throw things, or simply push the ladders away from the wall.

Siege towers

These were huge wooden structures that did the same job as a ladder but at the same time protecting the soldiers while they got up and over the wall. If you got a siege tower close to the castle, it could send an attacking force big enough to clear that section of the wall and create a safe passage for more to enter. The best defense against siege towers was to try to burn them with fire… And they couldn’t be used if the terrain wasn’t reasonably flat and solid… Or if there was a moat.

Trebuchet.

These were a type of catapults that used manpower, later counterweights, to launch big projectiles against or inside the castle wall. They were very effective in certain situations, but less so if the castle was higher than the surrounding terrain. They also needed to be very big if they were to do any significant damage to the wall. Another issue was that a tore down wall still left a large amount of rubble in the way of the attacker. There are examples where a castle resisted for months after the wall had been breached. One other thing, trebuchets and other forms of catapults could be used by the defenders as well.

throwing things on a castle
A Trebuchet of medieval design.

Sapping.

Sapping in warfare means digging under the wall, and under or close to the foundation so that the whole structure collapses. It was a very effective, easy, and economic way to bring down a significant part of the wall. The problem evidently was that it was slow. 

The different situations inside and outside the castle.

A standoff like those in a siege created very different conditions for those inside the castle compared to those outside. For both sides, time was crucial. 

The attackers had access to the surroundings and could have food and supplies sent to them. But if they were in enemy land,  the supply chain could be slow. And they always risked being attacked in the back by the defender’s reinforcements or their allies. 

  • During the siege by the Spartans of the city of Platea in 429-428 BC., the attacking Spartans first built a wall all around the city to prevent anybody from escaping or attacking from the city. Then they built another wall on the outside of their camp as a defense against any reinforcement from the Athenians. The sieging forces lived inside this corridor for several months before the city finally surrendered after 212 men successfully had breached the two defense palisades and fled.

A big problem for the defenders could be the lack of food or even worse, the lack of water. And the fact that they were cut off, without the possibility to send scouts and messengers to friends and allies… Unless they had some secret opening or tunnel. 

  • The St. Patrick’s Well in Orvieto, Italy, was dug in the 16th century to ensure water supply to the city in case of a siege. Orvieto is a rock rising some 200 feet off the surrounding terrain. The distance from the city to the groundwater level was too great, so a big cylindric hole was dug with a double, spiral road on the side… One for going down and the other for going up. The depth is 175feet (53 mt), and the diameter at the base is 43 feet (13mt).

More issues…

breaking the gate
Battering Ram

Both parts risked quarreling, and desertion among the soldiers. For the defenders, the civilians too could create problems. 

The biggest danger still was diseases. If the siege continued for months or even years, having men in closed encampments, as well as the closed spaces inside the castle, could be extremely hazardous. Especially since knowledge about germs, and viruses was close to inexistent. In human history, diseases were always much more fatal than war and starvation ever were. 

There was dialogue even in medieval warfare.

During the siege, there were normally also continuing discussions and negotiations between the parties. These depended very much on how the war developed. If the attackers had trebuchets, and siege towers, they would have a much stronger position in those negotiations. The same for the defenders. If they had food, they would be less eager to sign any peace treaties.

It is reasonable to conclude that any warlord would rather force a surrender than losing lives in battles along the castle walls. 

There are many examples of defeated armies being treated fairly because they surrendered and thus avoided further bloodshed. And there are many examples of defeated soldiers being lined up and killed just for opposing too fierce resistance…

But there are also examples of the opposite:

  • Lady Bankes defended Corfe Castle, Dorset, England, against 500 soldiers in the mid-1600. For three years with practically only a handful of servants, she resisted the siege of the Roundheads. In the end, she had to give up the castle as she was betrayed by one of her men. The castle was demolished, but Lady Banks suffered no penalty. Her heroic resistance had made such a strong impression on her adversaries, that they wouldn’t bring any repression on her. 

Forcing the main gate.

If you couldn’t breach the walls, another way to get in was to force the main gate. For this, you would need a ram, and rams could be a simple tree log cut down from one of the nearby trees. Or it could be an ingenious construction with levers and wheels and stuff. However it was made, you still had to get close to the gate. And that could prove deadly.

Caernarfon Castle Gate with murder holes.

The Caernarfon Castle in Caernarfon, Wales, UK has two main gates, the King’s gate, and the Queen’s gate. The King’s gate was never completed, but if it would have been, a visitor would have crossed two drawbridges, passed through five doors and six gates, portcullis, a right-angle turn before an enclosure from where you entered the courtyard. This whole route was overlooked by numerous murder holes and arrowslits. The latter is a vertical slit in the wall through which the defender could shoot. And the infamous murder hole is a simple hole in the roof. Was boiling oil used in sieges? Well, if it was, this is from where it would have come down on the intruder.

And why the five doors and the six gates? To create a trap for the enemy. Inside the sidewalls and over the roof, there were corridors where defending soldiers could move perfectly safe, and one by one kill off the attackers trapped inside the space between two doors or two portcullis.

By far the best way to conquer a castle. 

There was one last trick that guaranteed success and would save numerous lives on both sides. And that is to enter with deceit or betrayal by someone inside. It has happened many, many times over the centuries. 

  • In the fictional siege described by Homer in the Iliad, The Achaeans conquered Troy with a hollow, wooden horse. From inside the horse,  Achaean soldiers sneaked out, opened the big gate, and Troy was sacked.
  • One of the many Sieges of Antioch (Antakaya in today’s Turkey) was fought between the Crusaders and the Seljuks. In October 1097, Bohemond of Taranto besieged it with 40.000 men, but from that point until June 1098, they were not able to overtake the garrison. In winter the situation became very difficult in the Crusaders’ camp, with a shortage of food, problems with supplies, and constant attacks from the Turks. In May, as reports came in about a Seljuk relief army led by Kerbogha, Bohemond used his contacts with a Seljuk tower guard named Firouz. Firouz agreed to let the Crusaders through, in change for money and a title. So after 8 months, Bohemond could finally conquer the city, and massacre the population – military, civilians, Muslims, and Christians alike.

The political context.

Another important role did acts of submission play. Very often wars were fought to win loyalty and subordination. The Emperor of a large territory couldn’t even dream of controlling his domains without loyal vassals. And so, often it was more important to gain trust and fidelity from the defeated than simply to cut their heads off. This could be done by oaths, humiliation, or acts of subordination. All this was from a political point of view, a very delicate matter… Kill everybody or treat them fairly?

  • When Alexander the Great marched against the Achaemenid Empire, he easily conquered and gained subordination from all of the cities on the Mediterranean coast of what is today, Syria and Lebanon. He subsequently treated them fairly. When he came down to Tyre, that changed. The citizens put up resistance and Alexander had to siege the city for 6 months and build a causeway one kilometer straight out into the sea to be able to get close enough with his siege towers. That failed and thousands of his soldiers were killed. He sent for more warships from his allies further north, and finally, after six months he could enter Tyre. The King wasn’t happy… He immediately killed 6000 soldiers, and sent the remaining 30.000 men, women, and children to slavery, except for 2000 whom he crucified right there on the beach for everybody to witness.

But how much good virgin olive oil was there?

Oil wells existed in China, and the middle east already thousands of years ago, But it wasn’t until the 19th century, that commercial oil and petroleum became available to the general public. Vegetable and animal oils were used and still are, for cooking. But before 1800 non-mineral oils were used for much of what we use mineral oils for today, as well. From making soap to treating leather and wood. It was possibly even used for mechanical lubrification. 

Interestingly it was essential for fire arrows and other thermal weapons. Remember that the best way to defend yourself against many of the Seige weapons was to put them on fire.

In some regions, vegetable oils were abundant, such as the Mediterranean region. But it still probably wasn’t abundant enough to be used in battle… Not even around the Mediterranean.

Was boiling oil used in sieges, even if there were perfectly valid alternatives?

And what were those alternatives?

Well, I would think the throwing was the main thing here. Throwing things at the enemy from the wall, or from a murder hole, was perfectly safe, and could range from being a nuisance to being a deadly threat. 

There are many records of hot water being used. And quicklime, hot coal, and hot sand. The sand is interesting, as hot or cold, having sand inside a medieval iron armor wouldn’t be a very nice experience. 

fly photo Carcassonne
Carcassonne

Other testimonies include dirt, rubble, rocks, tar, and even excrements from humans and animals, as well as urine. And of course, they could shoot. Arrows coming in from a murder hole at close range make a lot of damage.

  • Carcassonne in southern France was besieged by Charlemagne in the 8th century. After six years of siege, the food inside the city was almost completely finished. The ruler, Lady Carcas, decided to feed the only remaining sack of wheat to the only remaining pig. Then she shot it over the wall with a catapult. When Charlemagne saw the well-fed hog on the ground, he concluded that the city was well-supplied and decided to lift the siege. A cute narrative. Unfortunately, it seems to be just a legend.

Final thoughts.

We don’t have any exact statistics of what was thrown on the enemy during the sieges of the past. Was boiling oil used in sieges? We know with reasonable confidence that it happened. Still, I would consider two very important facts:

  • Oil was expensive and often there wasn’t much around.
  • As it was the same oil they used for cooking, at least mostly so, Throwing away a resource that could prove essential if the siege would pursue, wouldn’t have been a smart move. Food and water were after all fundamental for resisting inside the castle.

Was boiling oil used in sieges… ever?

These are some of the sieges where we know with reasonable confidence that burning oil was used by the defenders:

  • The siege of Yodfat (Israel) in 67 AD.
  • The siege of Orléans (France) from 1428 to 1429.
  • The Great Siege of Malta in 1565. 
  • The Siege of Sommières (France) in 1573.

… and probably many more that we just don’t know about…


Back to the top of the page

Conclusion.

Well, we know it happened, but it probably wasn’t very common. Oil was too precious to just be thrown away.

impenetrable walls
Fenis Castle, Valle d’Aosta, Italy

home

sources

The Mansfield Reformatory

Mansfield Reformatory

Mansfield Reformatory, aka Ohio State Reformatory, is said to have been a particularly inhumane environment for the prisoners. That resulted in Mansfield Reformatory today being one of the most haunted places in the US…

Mansfield Reformatory
Courtesy of Mike Sharp under the CC BY-SA 1.0 DEED license.

Ohio State Reformatory

Correction facilities all over the world are filled with suppressed anger, unspoken despair, and insufferable anguish. Through the centuries they have gathered long lists of sad stories and tragic characters. Death was always a loyal companion to most in these godforsaken environments… And still is today. Life in prison is hard.

It is not difficult to see a connection between the nature of the activity in a prison and paranormal activity. Many stories about ghosts and hauntings originate in violent and unjust deaths, and nowhere are those more common than in prisons. As a result, many of the world’s most haunted places are those where people have been incarcerated… In older times castles and strongholds, in the last few hundred years in state prisons and reformatories.

In the US there are haunted prisons in every state… From Alcatraz in San Fransisco to Eastern State Penitentiary in Philadelphia, from Wyoming Territorial Prison in Laramie to the Old City Jail in Charleston.

But maybe the most terrifying of them all is the Ohio State Reformatory in Mansfield, Ohio

A short history.

architect of the Mansfield reformatory
Levi T. Scofield

The beginning of the Mansfield Reformatory can be dated as far back as the 1860s when 30 acres of land were purchased for the new institution. Ohio already had two facilities, the Ohio State Penitentiary, in Columbus which functioned as a high-security prison, and the Ohio Reform School outside Lancaster for boys between 8 and 18 years of age. But the state needed something in between. So in 1886, the construction of the Mansfield Reformatory started. It was intended as a Reformatory halfway between a prison and the Boys’ Industrial School. The inmates were supposed to be prepared, educated, and reformed to be able to retake their positions in society. They were supposed to be first-time offenders only, and the age of the inmates should be between 18 and 30.

Construction works didn’t finish until 1910 because of problems with funding. But already in September 1896, the first 150 men were transferred. These, together with other prisoners for the fifteen years to follow, helped with the completion of the building. 

The architecture, by the Cleveland architect Levi Tucker Scofield, was a result of the ideas of the time. Just by being in a morally uplifting environment, the prisoners were supposed to better themselves. Especially since the inmates were young and adaptable. 

From a model prison to Hell’s forecourt.

The Reformatory character changed after a few decades though. Although the intention always was to take on younger prisoners, not to have inmates that were convicted for the worst felonies, and to continue reformation programs to at least some extent, by 1930 the Mansfield Reformatory had become a real high-security prison, although for younger male interns.  

the hole Ohio state reformatory

Between 1920 and 1930, the average population in federal prisons tripled nationwide and between 1930 and 1940, it nearly doubled again. And after the devastating fire in the Ohio Penitentiary in April 1930, where 322 inmates were burned to death, the Mansfield Reformatory came under even more pressure. 

By then cells that were built for one prisoner housed two, and cells for two housed three or more. The sanitary problems were evident, and that definitely didn’t help when trying to keep interns and staff safe. 

From the early sixties, Mansfield Reformatory was classified as a maximum-security prison. 

Testimonies.  

Two prison guards were killed in the line of duty on prison grounds, Urban Wilford in 1926 and Philip Orleck in 1932. In 1948, two paroled inmates, Robert Daniels and John West, killed the prison farm superintendent John Niebel together with his wife Nolanda, and daughter, Phyllis. Before that, they had killed four more and injured several.  

But the inmates themselves took the hardest blow. In the hundred years of activity, over 200 interns died in the Mansfield Reformatory.  Some of them by suicide but most were assassinated by fellow convicted. Diseases also flourished in the cramped cell blocks.

One of the worst penalties was the so-called hole. These were Solitary Confinement cells, with only a toilet and a sink, but no bunk. The convict was fed only bread and water and had to sleep on the floor, sometimes naked. 

Ohio state reformatory

  –  There were so many cockroaches that you had to put toilet paper in your ears and nose to keep them out, said one inmate. The ones that got into your mouth just counted as an additional protein supplement.

Once, two inmates were put in the same isolation cell, dimensioned only for one person, After three days only one of them came out. The other was dead, killed by his cellmate.

The end and closure.

In 1978, the Counsel for Human Dignity filed a federal lawsuit on behalf of the inmates. At that time there were around 2500 interns on-site, while the official capacity was 1900. The lawsuit claimed that prisoners had to live in “brutalizing and inhumane conditions.”, and thus their constitutional rights were being violated. 

It took the court five years to agree upon a consent decree. The officials were to improve conditions while preparing for the closure of the Manfield Reformatory by 1986. The closing date was then extended and the prison was finally closed in 1990. 

While still officially a first-offender prison with convicts between 18 and 30, many exceptions from this rule were made continuously. 

Gary Mohr, former director of the Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction, reformed the whole organization in the last second half of the 80s. A Decentralized Management system was implemented, and not only in the Mansfield Reformatory but in all the state. It supposedly diminished problems in the prison and created a safer and calmer environment.

Many inmates from that time, do not always agree, though. They generally had to arm themselves at all times with razor blades, pens, and other self-made weapons for defense. Mansfield Reformatory was a very violent and unsafe place. Injures like cut wounds, and traumas to the head, arms, and legs after disputes were common. Murders occasionally happened within the prison, and they continued even after the reformed management was in place.

The many possible ghosts of Mansfield Reformatory.

So, finally to the ghosts. 

The many stories about hauntings were told between inmates and guards already long before the prison closed. Footsteps, whispers, thuds, and other strange, unexplainable noises could be heard from time to time. The many deaths within the premises make it difficult to determine who this ghost really is. Or even if it’s a single, definable entity, many entities, or just the building itself. 

Mansfield reformatory

There are locations though, that are more probable than others to produce paranormal phenomena. 

  • One such place is the so-called called “Jesus Room” in the west wing, accessible via a staircase off of the west cell block. It’s named so after a big Jesus painting present in the room. 
  • Another spot is the West Attic where supposedly banging and scraping can be heard even in broad daylight.
  • There is a room with a chair on the third floor of the entrance building. This is a blind room with no windows, and with just one piece of furniture, namely the wooden chair. It is said that if you close the door and turn off the light, the chair will have moved when you come back.
  • The hole, the solitary confinement cells.
  • The old hole under the barber at the east diagonal. This part is closed to the public, but people who have set foot there say that it’s the creepiest part of the whole prison.

The strange death of Helen Glattke.

Arthur Glattke was the warden of the Mansfield Reformatory from 1935 to 1959. He was much liked and respected by both the inmates and his staff. His wife Helen, born Bauer, was a beautiful woman and they and their two sons lived on the premises together with a few other families in managerial positions.

Around 10:15 Sunday morning, November 5, 1950, Helen Glattke was getting ready for church. She reached up to her closet shelf for her jewelry but for some reason, she put her hand on a hidden .32-caliber semi-automatic handgun. The weapon fell to the floor but by doing so it accidentally fired a bullet into her left lung. 

She died at Mansfield General Hospital two days later. 

Strangely, no outside investigation was carried out, and the death was labeled an accident. A number of gun experts stated that it is “very unlikely that a 32-caliber semi-automatic pistol could have discharged in the manner stated in the official account”. And the odd facts surrounding the case made rumors spread like wildfire inside the prison. 

“Helen could have found her husband with another woman, and Arthur had killed her to avoid a career-damaging divorce.” Arthur died nine years later in a heart attack at the age of 57. 

Soon after the death of Helen, many inmates, as well as guards, reported seeing the Ghost of Helen. The distinctive odor of her rose-scented perfume can be felt in her former quarters in the Entrance building.

Ohio hauntingsWhat do the YouTube experts say?

If you search Ohio State Reformatory or Mansfield Reformatory on YouTube, you’ll find a long list of videos. From self-proclaimed ghost hunters with just a cell phone to professional TV teams with all kinds of electrical gadgets and EMF toys. They are more or less all made in the same manner. And that’s the manner in which all the other ghost-hunting videos from all over the world are made as well.

Darkness, flickering lights from flashlights, scared faces, night-vision cameras, and the pulsating EVPs that every now and then say… “scratch”, which is interpreted as “Mike” or “Death”… And all the ghost hunters confirm in a low voice that:

  –  This is a haunted place… I feel uncomfortable here… There definitely is someone here with us…

But from the YouTube clips, there’s really not much certainty at all. We have many, actually loads of testimonies, audio recordings of voices, and videos of almost undetectable shadows moving around. But many uncertain, unconvincing testimonies do not add up to one true, convincing testimony. That’s just the way it is.

The Special Bias problems with the Mansfield Reformatory. 

The Mansfield Reformatory is a very popular ghost hunting site. And the reasons are two:

  • The structure itself. Even though the wall around it is gone, and so are all of the adjacent structures, the main building is awesome. The Romanesque- and Gothic style was inspired by European castles. Today, the totally grey facade, with its black, huge windows, gives it an eerie, uncanny atmosphere. It’s not strange that another popular name for the Ohio State Reformatory was Dracula’s Castle. And inside, with its cramped prison cells, long corridors, old, molded walls, and rusty steel bars, it’s even worse. It’s a scary place. 
  • The management focuses quite a bit on ghost hunts and other paranormal events. They take part in national and international events with various spooky themes, and they actively try to profile the Mansfield Reformatory as a haunted location.  
Mansfield reformatory

The new fashion of having old prisons being converted into haunted amusement parks has met criticism. Some social workers, scientists, and historians call it a distraction from the grim realities of the criminal justice system. We turn a violent and tragic past into a tourist attraction. 

This kind of activity makes it even more difficult to find the real deal under all the fluff. Every Youtuber wants substance to get visitors and likes, and if the big channels are ready to fake footage and recordings to make a good show, what should prevent the less resource-full small YouTube channels to do so as well? We need to try to penetrate the obvious fakes to see if we can find something true underneath.

Paranormal investigations of Mansfield Reformatory.

Real, true, skeptical investigations are always hard to find. Here’s a list of the famous TV channels that have had their ghost hunting program series covering Mansfield Reformatory on various occasions:

  • Ghost Hunter (Sci-Fi channel) was there in 2005
  • Ghost Adventures (Travel Channel) was there in 2009
  • Ghost Hunters Academy (SyFy) was there in 2009
  • Inside Secret America (National Geographic) was there in 2013
  • Ghost Asylum (Destination America) was there in 2015
  • BuzzFeed Unsolved (BuzzFeed) was there in 2018
  • Portals to Hell (Travel Channel) was there in 2020

As you see it’s been quite a flow at the Mansfield Reformatory. But not much solid and useful has come out of it. It’s an endless row of flickering footage, mumbling voices, and the ever-present pulsating EVPs. 

prison 1900
Courtesy of Brenda Gottsabend under the CC BY-SA 3.0 DEED license.

Conclusion

No, sorry but no serious investigation has ever been made in the Mansfield Reformatory. As long as you don’t count the many TV shows that have documented the prison. We just don’t have the facts. 

And the main difficulties when it comes to determining if there actually are ghosts roaming the property, are as follows:

  • The site is highly commercialized. The Mansfield Reformatory Preservation Society which is the present owner does an incredible job in preserving the property. But they don’t stop there. The goal is to be able to restore all of the interior as well as the exterior of the buildings. So far they’ve completed the restoration of the first floor, but they’d need funding for the continuing efforts. And that’s where the guided tours come in… Guided tours that cover everything from normal tourists visiting, to nightly ghost tours and Shawshank Redemption tours. All of which profit from the rumors the Mansfield Reformatory has of being one of the most haunted places in the US. We just can’t tell if the many stories are legit or if it’s just PR. 
  • The Mansfield reformatory is a very scary place by itself. Its atmosphere is that of an old haunted castle. And we know that the human brain is easily manipulated. I would say it’s much easier to imagine sounds, shadows, and touching in a vast correctional facility than elsewhere. Especially after dark. And all of the ghost hauntings are carried out after dark.

Janice Urban of the Mansfield Reformatory Preservation Society:

  –  I’m never afraid in this building. I can walk in here at any time and I’m never uncomfortable at all.

Final words

And I would actually agree with her. I do not feel any special hauntings or any sort of negative energy inside the Mansfield Reformatory. It’s just a fascinating building with a fascinating history… Very sad and disturbing but fascinating. There is no need to add Ghosts and Phantoms to it. It is quite enough just by itself.

The Mansfield Reformatory has its own merits, its own memories, and most of all, its own many real-life stories. We should respect that, and remember her hundred years of history and maybe we can learn something from it. 

… But please, make up your own mind.

haunted mansfield reformatory

Check out this photo, and read the article by Ryan Clark.

… I’ve traveled the country seeking out the weird and fantastic. I’ve been to supposed haunted houses and asylums. I’ve searched the skies for UFOs and hunted the woods for cryptids.

Never have I seen anything that made me truly question what I know. And I want to see something. I do. It’d just never happened.

… That is, until I visited The Ohio State Reformatory.

And check out this video. Are the claims credible?

Fun facts

  • The east cell block in The Mansfield Reformatory is the biggest free-standing steel cell block in the world.
  • Many TV shows and movies have used the intriguing interior of the Ohio State Reformatory for shooting prison scenes. The most famous being The Shawshank Redemption from 1994 (who actually used it for most of the scenography of the film), and Air Force One from 1997. Tango & Cash from 1989 shot various prison scenes inside while the prison was still in use.
  • The ground where the prison stands were previously used as a training camp for soldiers in the civil war. It’s been suggested that some of the ghosts derive from that time.
  • Warden Arthur Glattke was a creative person. In line with the ideas of the time, he installed loudspeakers and played music in the cellblocks. It was supposed to have a calming effect on the inmates. 
  • You could say that the film The Shawshank Redemption saved The Ohio State Reformatory. It was planned to be demolished. Then Castle Rock Entertainment needed the location for its film project and the demolition had to wait. After filming had ended, a local group of enthusiasts called The Mansfield Reformatory Preservation Society bought the estate for a symbolic $1. For that price, they are compelled to restore and maintain the buildings. 
  • Today The Mansfield Reformatory generates $16 million annually.


Back to the top of the page

Conclusion.

It is difficult to say for sure because of all the prejudice and commercial interests in the building. It’s a creepy place, but I don’t see any signs of real paranormal activity.

An extra star just for the awesome environment, and the fascinating history.  

 And The Shawshank Redemption is an awesome movie. You should see it if you haven’t already.

home

sources

Were there music videos before MTV?

Were there music videos before MTV?

The history of music videos starts somewhere in the 20th century. But were they around before MTV started in 1981? Is the format of music videos older than that?

What is a music video?

A music video is a short film that illustrates, comments, or at least in some way interprets the music within the video. It is mostly relatively short, as it reflects the song, although some videos can have substantial parts before and after the music, and thus become longer.

It is an artistic format that in some way promotes the song and the band/singer in the video. 

It is also disputable if simply shooting an artist playing his music, really is to be regarded as a music video. The format suggests some creative touch to the footage even if it centers around a live performance.

What is MTV?  

For those of you who don’t know, MTV is an American Cable TV channel centered around Music. The channel started out in 1981 as a music video-only TV, where so-called Video Jockeys presented bands, singers, and musicians for the audience, playing their videos. 

It later developed into a more complete and complex channel with reality, drama, and comedy TV shows, live concerts, and documentaries. 

But why focus on MTV? Well, the cable channel was closely connected to the format and was fundamental in the history of music videos. Without MTV, the music video would probably never have become what it is today.

The first music video ever.

With the definition above, the history of music videos started in the 60s. But long before that, there was music and images tied together in an expressive and imaginative way…

  • history of music videosIn the very first years of 1900, something called illustrated songs were widely performed in vaudevilles, theaters, and nickelodeons. The illustrated song consisted of music, often a singer accompanied by piano. Together with the song, still-, or moving images projected from glass slides were shown. They were often done before the show, and in the case of nickelodeons, after, or in between at reel changes.
  • Before

    sound movies had conquered the world in the early thirties, there were the “talkies”. These were the first steps toward full-length

    films and they were immensely popular, especially in the US. The first sound systems in the mid and late twenties had a synchronized disc instead of the soundtrack printed directly on the film itself. For technical reasons, the talkies had to be short and they were particularly suited for music/songs. Many of our greatest sound-film movie stars started out in these short films. 

  • The Bessie Smith short film “St. Louis Blues” from 1929 has some of the music video features mentioned above. It’s set in a bar with extras and the chorus placed around the tables. Mrs. Smith acts naturally at the counter, fingering a beer in front of her. It’s very far from the normal stage performance, and could, if you stretch it a bit, be regarded as the very first music video.
  • From 1939, the Mills Panoram offered 3 minutes-musical videos from a wooden furniture-like movie jukebox. It was often seen in bars, in nightclubs, and in restaurants as a curiosity of modern society. For 10 cents you could see a b/w “soundie” with a random famous singer.
  • In the 60s the Panoram-idea was reinvented with the French Scopitone and the Italian Cinebox. These had films in color, a choice of artists, and much better audio- and video quality. Still, they had a hard time competing with TV.

Why were music videos made before MTV?

The TV entered our homes after WW2. But it wasn’t until the late 50s that we started to have some serious TV listings. In those days, many TV shows and programs weren’t perfectly timed and the birth of TV advertisements made TV schedules unpredictable. Often there were spaces of 5, 10, or even 15 minutes between TV shows that needed to be filled with something. The short 3 minutes music video format was perfect for this. 

history of music videos
Nat King Cole

Jack Teagarden and Phil Moore, together with Louis Snader who funded the enterprise, invented a 3-4 minute format aimed at TV and featuring some of the best singers and musicians of the era. Nat King Cole, Duke Ellington, Count Basie, Cab Calloway, Sarah Vaughn, and Lionel Hampton are just a few names on the Snader Telescriptions team.

These are sometimes labeled the first music videos, but the problem is that they were pretty much just filmed gigs. And if we need creative video editing to be able to call it a music video, we have to wait another ten years. 

In this category, we have the music video credited by the Guinness world of records as the first ever. In 1958 Jiles Perry Richardson Jr, also known as The Big Bopper, recorded the superhit Chantilly Lace together with two other songs. 

Check it out yourself to see if you agree with Guinness…

Films

To distinguish a music video from a full-length film is not difficult. The film is much longer and usually has a different type of plot. But in the sixties, there were movies that contained songs with footage that if you cut them out of the film, they would fall into the music video category.  Two films are worth mentioning here:

The Beatles’ first music video.

In 1966, the world’s best-selling and most famous pop band, the Beatles, stopped touring. They sort of got fed up with the tight schedule, the screaming fans, the impossible playing conditions, the hotels, and the constant traveling. Instead, they started recording short promo videos for their newly released singles. 

The first one was We can work it out, coming out more or less like a straight-up concert gig in a studio. But already a few months later they released Paperback Writer and the style was different. Now there were inserts of the band members not playing but doing other things or just posing. In 1967, the videos Strawberry fields and Penny Lane showed even more creative tendencies, and so the modern music video format was born.

Why did they start making music videos?

The reasons for producing music videos were always to promote the artist or artists. From the beginning of the 20th century until today, advertising and selling was always the goal. Today the music industry has undergone a true metamorfosi. There is much more money to be shared from many more sources. But the music video is still one of the major tools for reaching the audience.

A good video can reach billions. The song Despacito by Luis Fonsi has an astonishing 7,4 billion views on Youtube. Compare that to the Mills Panoram at the entrance of the nightclub in the 1920s and its total public of maybe a few hundred inebriated guests.

live performance

Interestingly, today’s music-stars generally make much more money on live performances than they do on copyrights from music files and videos. So, even though artists proportionally make less direct money from the music videos, They have an increasing impact on the artist’s possibility to promote those prosperous live performances.

Today, the music video boosts much more than just the song. It is selling a whole package in which the image and personality of the artist are the main features.

How were music videos made before MTV?

After the Beatles’ first videos in the mid-60s, many other singers and bands started making creative videos showing more than just them playing the music. The form was new and nobody knew for sure where it was heading. Without complex video editing programs, the products were quite simple. Still, many of the directors of the first releases showed a strong desire to experiment. Here is a random collection of some of the videos from that time :

The first music video on MTV.

MTV was launched on August 1, 1981. The first video] was the Buggles with Video Killed the Radio Star, followed by Pat Benatar’s You Better Run. The idea was to play music with music videos around the clock. But although the idea was revolutionary and the concept a winner, the channel struggled in the beginning.

One reason was the simple lack of videos. There were so few around that MTV had to let the VJs talk too much, they had to use concert footage, and they had to repeat the artists that actually produced music videos a bit too frequently.

But after Viacom bought the channel in 1985, together with a broadening of the music segments, MTV slowly grew until it totally dominated music promotion. In the late 80s, and the 90s as much as 90% of an artist’s total budget for promotion went to MTV. 

… And at that point everybody was making music videos. But that’s a subject for another article.

I should mention Thriller by Michael Jackson. It aired in December 1983, and it opened the doors for Afro-American artists, who before that were rarely seen on the channel. Apart from the racial issues, the spectrum of music styles widened significantly after Thriller. Soul, R&B, Rap music entered the previously Rock-based channel, and that helped in building the totally dominant position MTV reached in the late 1980s. Thriller is regarded as one of the most influential music video of all times.

Music Videos – Records

These records are evidently subject to interpretation. The format is not defined, and what is or what is not a true music video can be debated. 

  • First ever…   1958 The Big Bopper, with Chantilly Lace.
  • First ever…   I would put my money on one of the early Beatles videos. Penny Lane, Strawberry fields, but the first was obviously Paperback Writer.
  • Longest ever…   Could be Ghost by Michael Jackson, 38 minutes. 
  • Longest ever…   Or it could be Level of concern by Twenty One Pilots, with an astonishing 4264 hours (… yes, that’s 177 days, 16 hours, 10 minutes, and 25 seconds, puh!). But that’s a loop of the three minute-song where fans were invited to send their own videos to the song. Your choice if that’s a true music video.
  • Most expensive…  Scream by Michael and Janet Jackson. 7 million dollars was the price tag.
  • Most influential artist…   Maybe Beyonce. Rolling Stones has her Formation video from 2016 as the best music video ever. Single Ladies won three Grammys, as well as a truckload of other awards, and is regarded as one of the best and most innovative videos ever. 
  • Weirdest music video…  Now, there’s quite a pick. Here are a few:

… But there are many, many more.


Back to the top of the page

Yes, music videos are definitely older than MTV. It’s just that the definition isn’t all that clear, and depending on what you consider a music video, the starting point changes.

home

sources

Poveglia… A story about the Black Death, and sadistic scientists. But are the atrocities true? Is Poveglia a few miles outside Venice, Italy, the most haunted place on earth?

Poveglia… A story about the Black Death, and sadistic scientists. But are the atrocities true? Is Poveglia a few miles outside Venice, Italy, the most haunted place on earth?

poveglia
Poveglia – Courtesy of Marco Usan under the CC BY 3.0 DEED license.

Poveglia Island.

Just a few miles south of Venice, Italy, inside the lagoon, there’s a solitaire triangle-shaped island. It is one of many deserted islands around Venice… Islands that once were flourishing with people, livestock, houses, and squares, but which now are home to rabbits and seabirds. 

Poveglia is different only through its name. While names like  Madonna del Monte or Isola Campalto slumber away in the shallow waters, Poveglia has become famous all over the world. And its fame is intimately connected to paranormal activity. 

Poveglia – Known from TV.

In 2000, The Fox Family created a series called The Scariest Places on Earth. The idea was to let an ordinary, or reasonably ordinary family, travel to haunted and scary places, and document their experiences. Episode nr. 23 is called The Island of no Return and the destination was obviously Poveglia. The episode aired on August 19, 2001, with a follow-up on August 24, 2001. 

poveglia

The style was innovative, and the series was a success. It continues for five seasons 2000-2002, and 2005-2006. In the Poveglia episodes, the history behind the hauntings is thoroughly explained. And this is how it goes:

The Plague

The Bubonic Plague hit Venice more than 60 times from 1348 until late 1700. Every time it brought sufferings beyond our imagination. On occasions the effective Venetian quarantine system could block it before it became explosive, but other times that was not the case. 

1348, 1423, 1575, and 1630 stand out as years when the epidemic killed between a third and half of the city’s population. The other waves of disease, around 60 in 450 years were less disastrous thanks to an effective quarantine. The word quarantine derives from the Italian word for 40, quaranta, and it determines the number of days persons and goods had to wait before entering the city.

Still, in times of pestilence the two quarantine-islands, Lazaretto Nuovo, and Lazaretto Vecchio, weren’t enough. And that’s where Poveglia comes in, at least according to Fox Family. Those who were most severely ill were shipped to Poveglia. But the island wasn’t really a hospital. It was just a place for people to die. They were dropped off and that was that.

poveglia
Equipment to be used in case of Plague-infected patients.

In the program, it’s stated that in some parts of Poveglia Island, as much as 50% of the soil consists of ashes from burnt human bodies.

The mental institution 

But the horrors do not finish there. In 1922, after being abandoned for many years, an asylum was built. New ideologies were at hand and a brand new leadership. The Fascist state needed places to put away the mentally ill. 

However, at some point in the 20s, a particularly dogmatic, and eager fascistic professor became chief physician on the island. In those days lobotomy was thought of as a normal and efficient therapy for mentally ill patients. And as they didn’t really have any anesthetics, and the patients were mad anyway… 

It is said that the screams from Poveglia could be heard to the Lido island and even all the way to Venice on calm summer nights. 

poveglia

The doctor died in 1942 and that too is a disturbing story. All through the 20s and the 30s patients and personnel had been complaining about strange lights, shadows, and voices around and inside the buildings. But nothing was ever investigated or done to prevent such a phenomenon. In 1942 the doctor finally snapped. He ran through the rooms and out in the open as if he was possessed, Screaming in fear he rushed to the old bell tower, up the stairs, and threw himself out the window. 

Somebody said that he didn’t die on impact, but a fog rose from the trees behind the building, closed in to cover his body, and choked him to death.

The final years of Poveglia – the haunted island.

After the war, the island was made unreachable. Poveglia became strictly forbidden and illegal. You can’t reach it without bribing some courageous taxi driver or having your own boat. And you would still risk a heavy fine.

The locals don’t go there anyway, it’s too risky. Screams, and cries for help are still heard from the dark ruins… And it’s said that fishermen, still catch human bones in their nets if they try their luck too close to the shores of the scariest place on earth… Poveglia.

Poveglia after Fox Family.

For 20 years there has been a steady flow of mostly young people, YouTubers, and non, going to Venice just to experience one of the scariest places in the world. Just search YouTube for Poveglia, and you’ll have a vast choice. 

Unlike many other haunted locations, the tourist industry of Venice doesn’t depend in any way on ghost-related tourism. Venice is already a huge tourist magnet as it is. And as Poveglia doesn’t offer anything by itself, there’s no money in it for anybody… Maybe except for the Taxi driver who will take you there. That fact alone could actually indicate real paranormal activity on Poveglia Island… Real supernatural sightings.

But it doesn’t, it doesn’t prove anything. And the reason is simply that all I’ve told you so far, all that The Scariest Places on Earth claims, and all that’s said in all of the other videos out there… Well, it’s simply not true.

povegliaHow to do a TV show.

The problem was that Fox channel did a TV show, nothing else. They put in footage and info to make an interesting program. The The Scariest Places on Earth series was even involved in a few controversies regarding paid actors, and falsified information. The way I see it, they were doing good broadcasting… A show. It wasn’t the news, it wasn’t a documentary… It was a TV show.

But somehow, their statements became common knowledge, and then somehow they became actual facts.

Seven years after Fox Family, Travel Channel created their own version of reality-supernatural-TV: Ghost Adventures. The layout was the same and in 2009 they too visited Poveglia. And the same story about the Plague victims and the mad doctor was told. Their program was even aired on Friday the 13th of November 2009, to make the most of the ghostly feeling.

So, what is the truth behind it all?

The true truth is that Poveglia never was a Plague island. And it never was a real hospital. In late 1700, Venice’s two hospital islands Lazaretto Vecchio and Lazaretto Nuovo, were old and they had suffered flooding (Not unusual in Venice…). So the city council discussed building a brand new facility on Poveglia. The plans were only carried out partially and only from 1814, though.

When the very last plague-infected ships came to Venice in 1793 and 1799, they were sent to Poveglia Island. 12 sailors died. We even have their names, and we know where they were buried.

In early 1800 it continued hosting arriving ships and sailors. But at this time the Bubonic Plague was over in Venice. It played an important role in the 1831-1837 cholera pandemic. And victims were buried in the new cemetery on the island. 

poveglia
Psychiatric Clinic

And there was no asylum. There was a geriatric clinic. Venice at the beginning of 1900 was still a big city, with a large population. And it seemed like an excellent idea to offer green and healthy surroundings for the elderly of the crowded city. Poveglia was the perfect place and work began to prepare it with good living conditions. 

When doing so, they built a psychiatric clinic to treat any mental illness. That very sign on the wall, probably inspired someone to invent the story about the mad doctor. We cannot say anything for sure about the treatment of the patients there and then, We just don’t know. We don’t even know the name of the chief Physician.

The 20s and 30s were full of nationalistic ideologies and ideas about the purification of races. Surely the way they looked at psychological problems, and general treatment of the sick and elderly, was very different from what we think today. But the geriatric clinic at Poveglia was like any other geriatric clinic during that time… No more no less. 

It closed in 1968. And that’s when the last inhabitant left the island.

What do the locals say?

Well, the locals don’t say much at all. At the most, they raise their eyebrows and ask:

  –  What? Which island is infested by ghosts and phantoms, did you say? 

Because in Venice, nobody would dream of regarding Poveglia as haunted. There are other islands, and other places, even inside of Venice that are much more disturbing. Poveglia is just a calm, deserted piece of land where the Venetians sometimes go Sunday afternoons to have a picnic under the fruit trees.

And what about the scientists… What do they say?

CICAP, Comitato italiano per il controllo delle affermazioni sulle pseudoscienze (Italian Committee for the Control of Pseudoscientific claims), are astonished. One should be aware, that this is a more skeptical association than many other national societies investigating paranormal activity. But they are quite baffled by the interest that Poveglia suddenly has developed, mostly in the US. To them, Poveglia isn’t even worth investigating.

To conclude in the same line of reasoning. Poveglia isn’t haunted, and it isn’t very scary, more than the possible threat of falling roof tiles. There’s just nothing there. The buildings are falling apart, nature is reconquering what man has made, and the rabbits are multiplying rapidly. 

The island does have a very interesting history, though, A history of wealth from trading, wars, political intrigues, and exile in Venice. But in that history, there aren’t any thousands of dying plague victims, and there is no mad doctor. 

It’s just another island in the Venice lagoon.


Back to the top of the page

No, Poveglia is not the most scary place on earth. It’s actually not haunted at all… Not in any way whatsoever.

home

sources

Pendle Hill

Is Pendle Hill, Lancashire, one of Britain’s most haunted sites?

Pendle Hill

Is Pendle Hill haunted? No, it’s propaply not. There have been sightings but none are such that we can exclude explanations other than supernatural causation. Speaking about hauntings and ghosts and such always comes down to what you want to believe. In this article, I will lay out some of the historical facts and how they relate to the very few anecdotal evidence that exist around Pendle Hill.

Pandle Hill
Pendle Hill – Courtesy of Chris Heaton under the CC BY-SA 2.0 DEED license.

The background to the Witch trials

On a cold spring morning in the year 1612, a pedlar was walking on the road from Colne to Trawden Forest. This particular road is in England, Lancashire, some 20 miles west of Leeds. Back in the 1600s, this was a poor and dangerous part of the country, with bandits and thieves never too far away. The pedlar surely was watching his steps carefully as he wandered on with his merchandise on his back.

At a certain point, he spotted a young woman, dressed in ragged clothes, and with a friendly but soiled face. But John Law, as the pedlar’s Christian name was, didn’t slow down his pace. The girl asked him for some pins, but John still didn’t take any notice of her.

The curse that led up to the Pendle Witch trials.

We cannot say for sure how the two person’s interaction was. Maybe John was offensive, or maybe he was just a bit too friendly. Maybe the young woman was too perky and forward, or maybe she did try to steal the pins after all. What we do know though, is that the outcome of that meeting was to become one of the most famous witch trials in the history of Britain. And 8 women and 2 men would be executed by hanging before the year had ended.

The woman threw a curse at John, and he fell to the ground. He managed to stagger to an Inn close by, and there he lay down. 

Alizon Device

This is the name of the cursing woman and the reason why we know that she cursed John in the first place, is because she confessed. As soon as she got news of the pedlar’s condition, she was overwhelmed with remorse. She came to visit John, to beg him for forgiveness. And there the story could have ended. 

But fate wouldn’t have such a simple conclusion. 

John’s son, Abraham, denounced the occurrence to the newly appointed local magistrate, Roger Nowell. This was a very ambitious, and zealous clerk, and he immediately summoned Alizon, her mother Elizabeth, and her brother James. And anybody who knows anything about the methods that were used to obtain confessions from witches during the witch-hunts in Europe knows where we are going from here. 

witch trials
King James I

The bad timing for the witches of Pendle Hill.

Three circumstances are important.

  1. King James l was an eager witch-hunter. He strongly promoted hunting down enemies of the church, and he had written the famous witch-hunting-tutorial Daemonologie a few years earlier.
  2. With the reign of King James, after decades of conflicts, the protestants had finally defeated the Catholic church in Britain. At least at a political level. And Catholics were regarded as suspiciously close to witchcraft already because of their strange and dark rites. The territory around Pendle Hill had many prominent Catholic families.
  3. We already talked about Roger Nowell. His role in this story was probably decisive. 

The Trial

So, the accused started throwing testimonies, and allegations around. First on each other and then, when asked, on people outside the family. And that list obviously contained the enemies of the family and others that were particularly disagreeable… Such as Anne Whittle, the matriarch of the Chattox-family, and her daughter Anne Redfern. 

The Chattox were something of competitors to the Device family on the cunning-folk market.

For the poor, going to a doctor, or getting help from a solicitor was out of the question. If something went wrong, be it health-, legal-, or other practical matters, you just had to fix it yourself, or with help from friends and family. If that wasn’t enough, you could turn to someone knowledgeable in herbs, medicine, and spells. These women, because they were almost always women, lived right on the border of what was considered good and legal, and what was thought of as malicious and illegal. And they were the first to be accused of witchcraft. 

11 people were imprisoned in Lancaster Castle. After 4 months in a cold, damp, filthy, and small cell, where all the prisoners shared space, 10 of them were brought in front of the judge. Elizabeth Device’s mother, Elisabeth Southern, also called Demdike, had died in jail. She was 80 at the time.

A 12th indictee, Jennet Preston was prosecuted in York. 

Jennet Device

Roger Nowell had one key witness. The daughter of Elizabeth, and the sister of Alizon and JamesJennet Device. She was 9 years old. When she was put on a table to make her testimony, her mother, Elizabeth, was so furious, that she had to be taken out of the courtroom. 

With a steady voice and without hesitating, she spilled the terrible truth out on all those present at the assize. Her mother was a witch, her grandmother was a witch, and even her siblings were in on it. She sold out her whole family.

Then she went on accusing a whole lot of other people, who had attended a meeting at the Device’s house on Good Friday that same year. All of them dealing with black magic.

Witchcraft and the court hearings.

To a modern reader, having a nine-year-old as a witness can seem dubious. Small children can’t always know what’s right or wrong, and they certainly do not fully understand the consequences of their words. Even in those days, that was a general idea, and small children weren’t normally considered trustworthy enough to be brought into a courtroom.

Daemonologie

But King James had changed all that. In his book Daemonologie, he had declared that, when it comes to fighting witchcraft, any witness is credible… Children, mentally disabled, people with a conflict of interest… In short, anyone. And normal reasoning wasn’t always practiced.

Since witchcraft is a supernatural force, all common sense went out the window.

If the accused had an alibi, then she could have killed him anyway, with a spell, from a distance. If it wasn’t a murder but an accident, then the witch could make it seem that way to not raise suspicion. If someone else had done it, then the witch could have changed form and physical characteristics to resemble that person.

There simply was no way to really get off the hook.

… And so, nine of the ten accused were found guilty and sentenced to death by hanging. And it was mostly based on the witness of a nine-year-old.

Alice Nutter 

One person didn’t really fit in. Alice Nutter wasn’t poor, and she wasn’t accomplished in herbs and powerful brews. She didn’t associate with any of the other accused. But she had one suspicious quality… She was Catholic. It is probable that Jennet, or whoever put the words in her mouth, just threw in Alice Nutter as a bonus… That, and the fact that she owned land.

To perform the Catholic mass was a felony compared to high treason. And the King had made it illegal not to attend the Potestantic mass or not to take communion during that mass. Alice Nutter didn’t admit anything and pleaded innocence until the end. She actually didn’t say much at all. Possibly because she couldn’t reveal her and her family’s engagement in the heretical religion. 

The Executions

On the 20th of August 1612, at Gallows Hill, Lancaster, 8 women, and 2 men were hanged by the neck until dead. These were 

  • Alizon Device
  • Elizabeth Device
  • James Device
  • Anne Whittle
  • Anne Redferne
  • Alice Nutter
  • Katherine Hewitt
  • John Bulcock
  • Jane Bulcock
  • Isabel Robey

Alice Grey was found not guilty.

  • Jennet Preston was executed in York on July 29, 1612.
  • Elizabeth Southern (Demdike) died in prison.

So, are these witches still haunting Pendle Hill?

First of all, Pendle Hill is a truly magical place. Its naked, grass-covered slopes and the isolated position would be a perfect background for any paranormal activity, true or invented. And anyone driving the deserted, narrow roads up the hill, or between churchyards and ruins at night, is likely to see all kinds of things, regardless if they’re there or not.

pandle hill

And there have been numerous sightings of ghosts, spirits, strange lights, mists, and even UFOs on and around the hill. 

But are there any documented, verified, really true confirmed encounters with anything that’s not of the normal, everyday world?

First, let’s look at where these encounters are supposed to have taken place…

The most haunted spots are these.

The Malkin Tower, where the Device family lived, was demolished shortly after the trial. Today there are many locations for that building proposed by historians. The only thing we know is that it was on the east or south side of the hill. 

One possible location is here:

Another is here:

Other possibly haunted spots are Faugh’s Quarry, where the old Demdike supposedly met with the devil.

… Or this whole area:

… Or the churchyard of Saint Mary’s church in Newchurch:

Clitheroe Castle:

Possibly because it’s a castle, and those are obvious hot spots when it comes to haunted sites. It is on the other side of the hill though, and the ghosts you find there could be of a different nature and perhaps not connected to the witch trials.

Lancaster Castle:

Lancaster Castle is where Elizabeth Southern aka Demdike died and where all the witches spent four months before trial.

The sightings are not limited to certain buildings or geographic spots, though. People have had strange encounters all over the Pendle area. Even up, on the hill, as far as the summit lights and mists have been observed. 

pendle hillA few of the many observations…

  • Ashley Firth caught this image in the spring of 2019 when walking down the hill. It supposedly was a mist that appeared right in front of her showing one or possibly two faces. It then disappeared rapidly. Read the full article here.

Mists are very common when documenting ghostly phenomena. Very often they have natural origins.

  • Christine Hamlett snapped a photo in autumn 2015 at the Saint Mary’s churchyard in Newchurch-in-Pendle. Read the full article here.
  • In early autumn 2014, Alan Pickover met with an eerie ghost at Waddow Hall at Waddington, north of Clitheroe. He was monitoring the plume from a chimney stacks a few minutes after midnight when he spotted a huge hooded shadow making its way toward him. Alan retreated to his car and drove off.

… And then came television…

In 2004 the British paranormal reality television series, Most Haunted, came to Pendle. In October they made a three-day live Halloween-special transmission from various locations around the hill, and of course, it was a huge success. So big, in fact, that the series anchor, Yvette Fielding, afterward declared that the episode was one of, if not the most disturbing experiences she had ever had. 

TV-series on the paranormal are generally not a good source of documentation. The technique involves the usual handheld camera moving around too fast to be able to get a good look at what’s going on. And since they always film at night, with the night-vision’s grey/green-ish colors it’s even harder to get any good visual on the images. 

The medium, Derek Acorah, who tragically passed away in January 2020, conveniently used a whole lot of information that was easily accessible from any website or book about the Pendle-witch-trials. Even the most famous names, Elisabeth, and Anne Device, as well as Demdike were used. 

It’s still interesting documentation. Especially the second day.

prison cellAfter that, the sightings peaked.

From 2005 all the way up until 2015, Lancashire had 81 reported encounters of non-explained supernatural phenomena. Of those, no less than 23 were witches, which is 28% of the total. And that’s statistically a very big part. This is in line with the usual effect a TV show of this type has on the frequency of sightings. When a location gets publicity, the reason for that publicity is reinforced. In this case with more witches being seen.

Proof isn’t proof until it’s proven…

But unfortunately, none of these witches cared to leave any sustainable proof of their existence. The photos and videos are open to interpretanìtion, to say the least, and many of the supposed encounters were made by, or in the presence of, people who have a lot to gain from any positive exposure in this field.

In the area around the hill, there are numerous companies offering witch-hikes, ghost-walks, sleep-over, and tours in haunted hotels, and other locations. And much of the tourist sector in the area benefits from the witches even if it’s just indirectly. It’s simply good business.

But good business doesn’t mean it can’t be true. It is still possible that Pendle Hill really is a haunted territory… 

What does the research say?

Research is a big word, and when it comes to paranormal phenomena, the implication often outgrows the topic. Not much science is investigated in researching paranormal activity. I will refer to two British societies.

The SPR – Society for Psychical Research in London, England, has no reliable documentation of paranormal activity in the Pendle Hill area.

The ASSAP – Association for the Scientific Study of Anomalous Phenomena, England, has no reliable documentation of paranormal activity in the Pendle Hill area.

Conclusion

We don’t have very much to go on here. Yes, there are loads of testimonies and flickering lights on greyish out-of-focus filming, but that isn’t convincing. Adding the obvious historical background, and commercial interest in the sightings, I can’t give Pendle Hill a positive verdict. 

It’s a  truly awesome place for anyone who wants to spend some time in the barren countryside of east Lancashire. And the history of the witches is fascinating, as is the Hill itself, and the wonderful villages around it. But when it comes to haunted spots, it’s just not compelling. The witches that were brutally tortured and executed in thousands all over Europe have all the reasons to seek revenge. And the thousands and hundreds of thousands of women who were oppressed, exploited, humiliated, and abused in the centuries that followed, and are so even today, are all entitled to justice… In this world or from the world beyond. 

Demdike, Elizabeth, Anne, and all the others are seemingly quiet, though. What we can do is to let our voices be heard and to speak for them. And to speak for all the other women in this world suffering from persecution and injustice.

I give Pendle Hill one extra star for the documented historical background. As well as Yvette Fielding’s of Most Haunted statement that Pendle Hill is one of the most disturbing experiences in her career. 


Back to the top of the page

So, are there any witches?

No, not really. 

The history is fascinating, and the surroundings are beautiful, but when it comes to paranormal activity I would give Pendle Hill…

So, what happened to the young Jennet Device?

We don’t know how she managed after she sent her whole family to the gallows. But she turns up again in the records in 1634 when she’s accused of having killed a woman with witchcraft. But in 1634 the King was dead and King Charles I was in charge. He was much more of a skeptical, and he promoted sustainable proof rather than religious fanaticism. 

The main witness was a boy named Edmund Robinson, aged ten. When he finally cracked up and admitted that he had made it all up, he referred to an old story he’d been told. A story about ten witches on the slopes of Pendle Hill…

home

sources:

Is Sumerian the oldest language in the world?

Is Sumerian the oldest language in the world?

I usually claim that to understand the answer, you first have to understand the question. To me, that statement is something of a general truth, an axiom. But when you arrive at the question of languages, this becomes absolutely fundamental. To determine what is old and what is a language, we need to clarify what we mean.

Definition of the oldest language in the world.

Languages are in constant evolution. They come from somewhere, and they change as people move around, or are visited by other linguistic groups. The more influence a group has, from other groups, the more its language change

  • So, is it correct to say that a language that has developed less is older than a language that has developed more?
  • And when does a language become another language?

What do we mean by “oldest language”?

  • Greek is a very old language. The first writing is something called linear B, and it dates as far back as 1400 BC. The greek that Homer used for writing his bestsellers, Iliad, and Odyssey, is called Homeric Greek (… Obviously).  After Homer, there was great evolution and many changes to the language.
  • Latin is also a very old language. Latin is the base for numerous languages that developed in the territory of the Roman Empire, such as French, Spanish, Portuguese, Romanian, and Italian. The Italian language was somewhat determined in the 12th, and 13th centuries and formalized with the writings of Dante Alighieri in late 1200 and early 1300.
Homer
The Trojan Horse

A normal Greek-speaking person of today doesn’t understand much of ancient Greek, but it still holds the origins of the modern Greek language.

A normal Italian-speaking person of today doesn’t understand much of Latin, but it still holds the origins of the modern Italian language.

Greek is considered very old, and so is Latin. But Italian isn’t… Do you see the problem? Could it be that it’s just a matter of how you label a language?

The oldest written language.

Even though, when determining the oldest writings in history, you will have to face some of the same issues as with the only spoken ones, those without written documents. Writing is still a more solid ground to stand on. The written language has a document, something that’s physical, at least if it’s written on stone or clay. And the age of that document/thing can be determined and proven.

oldest language in the world
The Kish tablet

So, the oldest written thing is the Kish tablet. It’s a limestone tablet found in Iraq, in the Babylon province. It has an early form of partly syllabic, cuneiform writing probably in Sumerian. It dates from 3500 BC.

In Jiahu, China, some 100 miles, (150km) south of Zhengzhou, in 1989, artifacts were found containing writings that looked like very early Chinese symbols, dated to 6000 BC. The consensus among scholars is that these are not actual writings as the symbols don’t seem to contain any grammatical hierarchy. but rather only a simple geometric design.

Symbols of this character have been found in Serbia, Greece, many locations in the middle east, and other parts of the world. 

oldest language in the world
Bull, Hieroglyph from Deir el-Bahri ca. 2000 BC.
Bull, Lubang Jeriji Saléh, Indonesia. 40.000 years old.

Different types of writing.

Many language historians claim that the writing started in Mesopotamia, with the Sumerians, and the cuneiform script. Some think that the whole idea of writing then spread into other areas with merchants and diplomacy/warfare. The fact is that even if the Sumerians were first, we have many findings of other languages dated shortly after in the neighborhood. And we can’t know if there could be other examples of writings, that we haven’t found yet:

  •  In Egypt, the first known hieroglyphs are from around 3400 BC.
  •  In India, we have findings of the Harrapan script from around 3000 BC.

The most interesting aspect of the Jiahu-symbols is that they could be some sort of ancestor to the present Chinese Hanzi script, which is logographic writing, meaning the symbols are syllables or whole words rather than sounds. And that would make it by far the oldest written language still in use. 

But now we are talking about writings. Spoken Chinese is a completely different matter. 

But, for now, let’s stick with the Kish tablets for the prize as the oldest writing.

The oldest spoken language.

Determining the age of a language becomes much more difficult when you don’t have anything written. As we don’t have recordings or anybody old enough to remember, we will have to stick with hypotheses. And this is where the excellent historical linguists come in.  

  • When did humans start to talk?
  • At what point could our sounds be considered speaking?
  • And if it died out shortly after, should we still count it?

These are very interesting topics, and if you read on, I’ll get back to it, to the very first words any human being uttered ever.

But for now, the question has to be…

What is the oldest spoken language still in use today?

And we’re back to my example with the Greek and the Italian. We need to determine what “still in use” means. How far from the original can you get and still count it as the same language? Here are two examples of English. The first was from around 800 and the second was from somewhere between 1200 and 1500. How much of these languages do you understand?

Another aspect is to determine what we mean by spoken.

  • Does it have to be a mother tongue to be considered alive today?
  • Does it have to be used uninterruptedly, or could there be holes in the timeline?

Latin is a good example. Because it is still in use today. People know how to speak it. It is studied in schools and used by priests, singers, and doctors all over the world. But it’s not a mother tongue to anybody… And maybe it never was. 

Latin is not old enough to be regarded in this group of very old languages. But Sanskrit is. Sanskrit is definitely among the contestants, and some would argue that this branch of the Indo-European language tree is, in fact, the oldest. 

The oldest language in the world – Sanskrit and Hebrew.

Sanskrit’s first appearance comes in the ancient Indian collection of Vedic hymns, Rig Veda from about 1400 BC. Veda means knowledge, and these hymns are religious and metaphysical verses dealing with the universe, God, and the meaning of life. Two problems arise:

  1. We don’t have Rig Veda. Much like we don’t have any original of the Bible, The oldest written text of the Rig Veda is from the 13th century AD. 
  2. Today nobody is born with Sanskrit as their mother tongue, but it exists as a religious and ceremonial language. Should it still be counted as the oldest language in the world?
Tamil language
The Rig Veda

Sanskrit is similar to the other Indo-European languages and probably descended from some common ancestor. Many words are close to those in Latin, Greek, and even English.

Talking about the Bible, Hebrew is also very old. Similar to Sanskrit, it is a religious language that was out of use for a long period of time. It was revived in the 1800s, and when the state of Israel was founded in 1948 it became the official language of Israel. But we don’t have the original writings of the Tanakh, the Hebrew Bible. The oldest complete copy is from around 1000 AD. Hebrew has some 5 million speakers worldwide, so it’s definitely live and kicking… But it was dead as a spoken language for over a thousand years. Do we count it?

More possible candidates.

  • Tamil, is another language claimed by some scholars to be the oldest language in the world. The first documents in Tamil are from the 6th century BC. But it is possible that the language is much older than that. It has an unbroken timeline and today more than 75 million people speak Tamil.
  • Chinese. 
  • Greek. (With the disclaimer above.)
  • Lithuanian. Just like all the other European languages, it has Indo-European roots. But while most other languages have developed and changed, Lithuanian has maintained some of its original features.  But does that make it older?
  • Farsi – Persian. Farsi is documented from around 500 BC. That is early enough. But the Persians have at least some relationship, cultural and linguistic, with the former inhabitants of their territory, the Sumerians. If you count them as Persians, then Farsi is by far the oldest language in the world. But to me, that would be a rather long stretch. Farsi is spoken by ca. 70 million people worldwide.

which was the first language?What defines a Language?

  1. A language is a mechanism for communicating with others, mostly of the own species.
  2. The language is sound-based or based on signs with the hands. The body-language expression doesn’t count in this case.
  3. It has to be variable.

Many social animal species can communicate vocally, by barking howling, snorking, squeaking, roaring, etc. But they are mostly limited to pre-determined sounds. We, on the other hand, can express an infinite amount of information based on the combination of syllables, and sounds.

The word house can be used in a variety of ways. You go to your house, or away from it, or it could be someone else’s house, or I could build a house… Or tear it down. It all comes down to where you put the prepositions, where you put the word inside the phrase, genus, the grammatical number, and many other possible variations.  And that’s just one, single word.

Our brother primates do not have a well-defined language. They have sounds, and they can be quite communicative, but they don’t speak. 

The oldest language in the world is sign-based.

Scientists have tried to teach chimpanzees to speak with words, but with little success. When teaching them to speak with symbols, they are much more fortunate. This could suggest that the origin of language lies in concrete symbols, rather than abstract words.

It’s a known fact that children with deaf parents, that is, children who have sign language as their mother tongue, so to speak, can communicate with words much earlier than speaking children. They learn their first words already at 6 months, and at around one year, they have a reasonable vocabulary, to be able to express simple phrases.  

Sometimes you don’t even need words…

Professor Michael Corballis Ph.D. suggests that the oldest language in the world originated from gestures rather than sounds. He proposes a very early start of the language process in early humans. As far back as 6 million years ago. And it started with hand-, and facial expressions. If you’ve ever seen a political discussion in Italy, you know what a likely theory that is.

Homo Erectus, our forefather, was an ingenious creature. He traveled, he spread, and he created settlements with different types of buildings, in a hierarchical structure. Could he have done all that without some sort of language? Homo Erectus didn’t have our vocal apparatus, he didn’t have all our muscles in the throat, the mouth, and the tongue. But he stood up. And by standing up he freed his hands for gestures, and he showed his face for expressions.

Final thoughts

Today there are more than 5000 languages on this planet. More than 5000 ways to express simple things, write poetry, or books, or cry out for help. But all these languages have some sort of common origin. They all started out somewhere as simple sounds and gestures. From there they evolved and became a full palette of humanistic wonders… Our modern languages. 

oldest language in the world

So, what is the oldest language in the world? If you’ve borne with me this far, you understand what I’m getting at. There is no oldest language in the world. Because they all come from somewhere and they go somewhere else. Every language is in a transformative phase between before and after. 

We can determine which is the oldest language in the world only by defining the criteria. And the result would change according to the criteria. 

So, yes, Sumerian is the oldest language in the world if you count written documents… And that’s not a bad criterion. 


Back to the top of the page

Conclusion

Yes, Sumerian is the oldest language in the world if you count earliest writings, and you consider both living and dead languages. 

home

sources

Did nylon get its name from the two cities, New York and London?

Did nylon get its name from the two cities, New York and London?

The reason for the story of the two cities.

Where does the name, nylon come from? A dear friend of mine once claimed that his boat was involved in how Nylon was named after the two cities, New York and London.

He was at the time the owner of a beautiful 47 feet motor-cruiser built in the 1930s. It was an extraordinary boat, shining copper, thick oak, velvet, and silk. A piece of old-age luxury reminding him of the old days, when the world was richer and simpler… At least for the British. 

Anyway, what he said was that his vessel crossed the Atlantic in the 30s. He had documentation of that. And that the owner at one time was an English scientist involved in the creation of Nylon. After a whisky or two in the deckhouse, overlooking the mouth of the river Hamble, the story got more detailed. 

Nylon name New York London.

Two scientists, one of them possibly Wallace Carothers, the inventor of Nylon, spent a few weeks on the boat going from London to New York. The passage gave them lots of time to discuss the denomination of the new discovery, in which they both were deeply involved. By the time they reached the big Apple, they had agreed upon naming the new fiber NYLON, from the start and finish destinations of their trip… Or more precisely, the finish and start, New York, and London.

Where does the name nylon come from?The story doesn’t really add up, though. 

  • First of all, nobody, going from England to the US with a small motor yacht, parts from London. He would part from, let’s say, Plymouth… Nyply. Maybe not a very good name for promotional purposes.
  • Secondly, there is no record whatsoever of any British scientist having had anything to do with the discovery of Nylon. Although much of the scientific expertise in many fields, still was concentrated in Europe before the war, Nylon was an American product. Developed by Carothers and his colleagues under the DuPont umbrella in the US. Carothers visited Europe twice in the mid-thirties. He was at the time suffering from frequent depressions and psychological illness, and it’s highly unlikely that he would have endeavored in any adventurous expedition over the Atlantic. 

Other possible explanations. 

Another myth claims that the two cities’ names were merged on an airplane when two chemists thought up the word on an intercontinental flight from London to New York. Not even that is plausible. 

Nylon new york london
Wallace Hume Carothers

When the first ever intercontinental passenger airline started in 1939, from New York to Marseilles, Nylon was already established. The big announcement of the new fantastic material occurred on October 27, 1938. The name, Nylon, was then repeated when another promotional push was launched at the New York World’s fair in 1939. 

So it’s highly unlikely that the two cities had anything to do with it. (Sorry buddy, your boat is just a boat…). 

Now You’re Lost, Old Nippon – NYLON, is another suggestion. Any smooth, almost transparent fabric was, traditionally, made from silk, and more than half of all silk worldwide was produced in Japan. That particular phrase could have meant thumbing the nose at the rapidly climbing industrial power of the east. 

So, where does the name nylon come from?

If it had nothing to do with either New York or London, where does the name nylon come from?

Nylon new york london

The scientific name is polyhexamethylene adipamide. But the label, Nylon, indicates not one material but a group of materials. In fact, nylon is used in a wide variety of applications. And it can be mixed with additives to achieve a vast number of different properties.

As the original name wasn’t very sexy, the marketers at DuPont were trying hard to come up with something more interesting. Carothers called his plastics Polyamide 66, or fiber 66. The two numbers have survived to modern times. The particular type of nylon that Carothers and his colleagues developed, is today referred to as Nylon 66, polyhexamethylene adipamide.

Soon after the product launch, representatives of DuPont declared that the name was random, at least more or less random. The -on at the end was just a general material kind-of ending, similar to other fibers, synthetic or non…Rayon, Cotton. The nyl didn’t really mean anything… 

Later explanations.

In a publication by DuPont from 1978, a more thorough explanation is presented. According to the authors, the process of finding a name was quite complicated. A list of some 400 names was put forth, many of which were immediately thrown out. F.ex. Duparooh – DuPont Pulls A Rabbit Out Of a Hat.

Where does the name nylon come from?

In the end the list was shortened to just a few names: 

  • Delawear – Delaware, the state where the production facility was located, and Wear.
  • Dusilk
  • Rayamide
  • Silkex

K. Gladding, the director of the Nylon plant suggested:

  • No-Run, as in no-unravel. Stocking made of this material didn’t unravel.

The last steps.

No run was a little steep to promote. In fact, the company suffered to some degree when claiming that these stockings were Strong as steel and smooth as a spider web. They were certainly strong, much more resistant than silk, but still, they weren’t unbreakable. And many women, trusting the DuPont’s claims, treated their new stockings carelessly, causing them to – right… Unravel.

Where does the name nylon come from?

When DuPont changed the campaign strategy to focus less on technical and scientific innovation, and more on the practical aspect, comfort, and style, the sales skyrocketed. In the first year after WW2, there were riots outside the warehouses, when production couldn’t keep up with the astronomical demand. In one occasion in Pittsburg, 40.000 women queued up for hours. The 13.000 pairs available sold out in minutes, leading to fights breaking out.

In the end, No-Run was just a little too provocative. So they changed the order of the vowels, Nu-Ron… Nuron. But that sounded too much like neuron, the brain cell. An L was put in… Nulon, the U changed to I… Nilon. Lastly the I was substituted by an Y to clarify the pronunciation. 

And there you have it, Nylon. From No Run, as in No Unravel.

Wallace Carothers tragically took his own life on April 28, 1937. 


Back to the top of the page

Conclusion

No, the name Nylon has nothing to do with New York and London. It was simply an imaginative description that was supposed to be selling. A good, catchy, word, easy to promote.

Nylon riots
American Ladies queuing for Nylon/Stockings after the war., Tennessee

home
sources

Was Football/Soccer born when a group of soldiers kicked an enemy’s cut-off head between them?

Was Football/Soccer born when a group of soldiers kicked an enemy’s cut-off head between them?

First of all, we’re talking about football/soccer… A game you play with your feet. And of course, the name indicates just that… Foot and Ball. But if you follow me back into the fog of the early football history, you will see that the distinction between Football, American football, and Rugby isn’t all that easy to grasp. Because they are all neatly tied together back there in the distant past.

The History of Football

In ancient China, as well as Japan and other eastern countries, they played football. Cuju (蹴鞠) is recognized by FIFA (Fédération Internationale de Football Association) as the oldest documented football-style game. It was played as far back as 200 BC in China, and it included many different styles. Often it was played as an exhibitionistic game with only one team. The idea was to pass the ball within the team and a single winner was declared at the end.

cuju

The ancient Greeks also played football, as well as the Romans… And probably every other group of people in the whole wide world. From Greenland to Australia, from America to Africa. We do not know exactly in what way these games were played, how the winner was determined, how the “ball” was made, and if they were allowed to use their hands or only kick the ball with their feet.

The reason for Cuju being declared the oldest documented football game in the world is obviously because it was documented. In China, writing was common knowledge and the Emperor kept logs of the various events. And so we have an idea about the game and the rules. 

From many other parts of the world, documentation started when people started writing about it. But we can not know for sure when football was born. There are findings older than those from China, for example in South America, but the problem is the same… The documentation. Without properly written descriptions, it’s hard to determine if a game is this or that, football or something else.

The Medieval game

It’s evident though, that different games involving a ball-ish thingy and a lot of youngsters running around have been around for a long time. But to distinguish true football from other ball games we need to determine a few attributes. 

  • It has to include a ball.
  • It has to be a reasonably big “ball”. One that is played with parts of your body, not with a racket or a stick.
  • It has to be competitive. And there should be lots of people in the field, teams, possibly more than one.
  • You should play it with your feet, kicking the ball… Wait, What?

And here’s where football shows its common origins with Rugby and American Football. 

Because the history of football shows that the vast majority of the different styles used hands and feet to move the ball… And many were exaggeratingly violent. If you want to have an idea of how it could have looked like back in the day, there actually is a medieval football game still played today… A game that has undergone few changes during the ages. 

The Florentine Football – Calcio Fiorentino 

Every year in June you have the possibility to see four teams of young hooligans play a tournament of two semifinals and one final. And what you witness is more of a group-MMA than actual football. It’s extremely brutal. Although modern rules are modified to avoid serious damage to the players, it’s still very different from a normal football match. 

This Italian football game was the first with rules written on paper, dating from 1580. Rules that involve 27 players in each team. A Strange feature is that the defenders are allowed to use any means to stop an attacker from reaching the home net and scoring. That includes tackling, throwing, hitting, but also fist-fighting.  

The game is very interesting not only because it’s an interesting game in itself, but also because it gives you an idea of what football could have been like in Europe in the middle ages. Because these games were widespread all over the continent… That is, in times when they were not prohibited. 

Because the violent nature of football made it a target for legislation. After a match, there could be players and spectators injured and also damage to property. Football suffered a ban or an intended ban in England in 1314, 1349, 1363, 1389, 1401, 1477, and 1540… And that’s just England.

Another interesting fact is that women’s football was not allowed in the English Football Association’s (FA) pits until 1971. The reason was that “the game of football is quite unsuitable for females and ought not to be encouraged”.

the ball of American and European football
These two balls are from the second part of the 19th century. Soccer/Football – Top American Football – Bottom They more or less have the same form and size.

The Ball

We don’t have good descriptions of the ball back in the earliest days of the history of football. There’s a note from China when they started using an animal bladder as the inner air-filled chamber. It replaced a feather-filled ball.

We can assume that the early balls were very different and that they took what they had close at hand to create it.

In the middle ages, the normal way to play was with a pig’s bladder… Or some other big animal’s. 

The task of inflating the ball was not for the squeamish. The pig’s bladder would be blown up while still in its very smelly state, solely by lung power down the snapped stem of a clay pipe inserted into the opening of the bladder.

With time the bladder was covered with pieces of leather stitched together to make the ball more uniform and less gross. Then came the development towards round balls. Something that was trickier to achieve. 

A non-spherical animal bladder can’t be managed very well with the feet, you can’t dribble, and you can’t control it. And just like in so many other fields, it could have been the technical progress that finally bridged over to banning holding the ball with the hands. It wasn’t until 1872, when the spherical ball became mandatory, that 100% foot-based football became at all possible. 

The hand-held ball games didn’t rely on bouncing and dribbling, and in 1892, Rugby got similar standards for their ball… But instead of a round ball, Rugby and American football use an oval one. 

Mob Football in Britain

From England, there are numerous articles and writings about football and football-type games played on fields or even in the streets in the middle ages. Often the teams were made up of schools or workers’ guilds, and just like the Fiorentine game, these mob football games were violent exhibitions. 

One of the earliest documentation from Ireland is from a protocol that tells of how Mr. John McCrocan was accused and charged of having Accidently stabbed Mr. William Bernard at a football game in 1308 in the city of Newcastle, County Down, Northern Ireland. 

I would like to see exactly how you do when you accidentally stab somebody…

The history of Modern Football. 

The history of modern football is intimately connected to Britain. We’ve already established that the game was played more or less everywhere, but it wasn’t until the 19th century in England that we started to have common rules. And common rules are needed if you would like to start playing matches, tournaments, and league football. 

In 1800, football was closely tied to schools and universities. Students all over Britain played football between themselves and together with their teachers. As the school system, back then, was mostly for upper-class children, they tried to limit the negative physical effects it had. Parents weren’t happy when their kid came home for Christmas leave with a broken jaw. 

Another important factor was the prospect to play with other teams from other schools. 

the history of footballThe first football rules and the path to the modern game.

In 1845 the Rugby School in Rugby, Warwickshire, came up with a set of rules. It was the first attempt to unify and organize football as a standard game. Not surprisingly these rules included throwing and holding the ball. 

In 1848 another set of rules was concluded in Cambridge. These were decided among representatives from the different schools, including Rugby, and were more similar to modern football/soccer. The Cambridge rules weren’t accepted everywhere and there was quite a bit of confusion when different clubs met. Even to a point that sometimes the rules had to be drawn up for that particular match and agreed upon by the two teams. 

The biggest issues were not so much the duration of the match, the number of players, and how to score. But the disagreements were mainly two:

  1. Limit or not, the amount of violence allowed between players. Some promoters were determined to make football a non-violent game.
  2. Running while holding the ball. Rugby- and Harrow-players promoted this, while the others did not.
The foundation of Football Association
Some of the Gentlemen who wrote the Cambridge rules.

The history of the English Football Association

FA (the Football Association) was founded in 1863, and they needed a set of rules that could be agreed upon by everybody. In autumn of that year, professors from the various schools met in a series of sessions to, once and for all, resolve the issues with the rules of the game. It didn’t work out perfectly, but at the end of the year, there was a new Association for the game and a set of rules to which at least most of the clubs could agree. 

Distinctive new laws were: 

  • Hacking – kicking the shins of the opponents – was banned.  
  • Running with the ball was disallowed.

They also decided how the goal should be, with two lateral poles and a string between them.

In 1871 the Rugby Football Union (RFU) was formed promoting what is today referred to as Rugby. Interestingly, the Rugby School football club didn’t join the RFU until 1890, as they refused to abandon the Hacking-tactic. 

football in a fieldThe history of American Football

On November 6, 1869, the first-ever American Football match was played. The game was played according to the English rules, which were somewhat confusing at the time. Obviously, the American style developed more into the Rugby-game than into the foot-based Cambridge game. And in 1880 the American football player Walter Camp invented a set of new rules and ideas, that started a line of evolution distinctly different from both Rugby and European football or Association football, as it’s also called.

So by the end of 1800, we have the three different branches, Football/Soccer, Rugby, and American Football. Of these the Football/Soccer branch is by far the biggest. In fact, it’s the most popular sport in the world, with the most players and the biggest audience.

father of american football
Walter Camp – The father of American Football

But what about the kicking of the head?

Well, this is a legend firmly rooted in the beliefs of more than one football fan in every corner of the world. But it is a legend, and as such, we can’t really tell how much accuracy there is to it. 

The tale goes something like this: 

During the times of the Viking invasions in the 11th century, some English peasants found (…or cut off) a head of a Danish soldier. They then kicked it between them, probably as a sign of defiance against the Danish oppressors. A group of kids saw them and as it looked like a funny thing to do, they copied them and the game of Football was invented.

Just the fact that the event has been dated from 300 AD. up until the French revolution, as well as in almost every corner of the British islands, should encourage reasonable doubt. 

I can’t say what happened a thousand years ago in Britain, but I can say that it wouldn’t have been the first time angry peasants cut off the heads of the invaders. I don’t think it was the origin of football though.

 


Back to the top of the page

Conclusion

No, Football wasn’t first invented in Britain and its origins are not from a Danish head. What the British did, was to put up a standard of rules, from which modern Football evolved. And those same rules became the backbone for both Rugby and American Football

Courtesy of Sjöhistoriska museet, Stockholm

home
sources